Discussion: View Thread

ENT-AoM Reviewing Update: Final Status!

  • 1.  ENT-AoM Reviewing Update: Final Status!

    Posted 02-29-2024 07:52

    Three Cheers for our incredible ENT Reviewers (and Associate Editors): They delivered and then some!  

    Sincere thanks to ENT Reviewers and AEs for their thoughtful and developmental feedback on the papers and symposia assigned to them.

    Tuesday, February 27th 'close-of-business' Reviewer Update:  

    ENT Division assigned 994 papers and 64 symposium proposals for review

    ENT Reviewers completed 3052 reviews! An IMPRESSIVE amount of work by any measure. Lets toast!

    The ENT Division review completion rate for Reviewers and AEs is 93.25% for AOM 2024! (Compared to AOM average of 88% across all divisions. Once again, ENT rocks!)

    We had 21 review invitations declined (.64%)

    As of Tuesday (Feb 27), there were still:

    In-Process = 51 Reviews (1.56%).

    !! NOT YET OPENED !!  = 149 Review Assignments (4.55%).

    As you know, no further extension to complete reviews is permissible by AoM.

    All papers and symposia received at least two reviews, with many receiving more. Specifically:

    2 reviews: 267 submissions (25.23%)

    3 reviews: 618 submissions (58.41%)

    4 reviews: 152 submissions (14.37%)

    5 reviews: 10 submissions (0.94%)

    6 reviews: 1 submission (.09%)

    Reviewers with highest number of reviews will be honored at the ENT Division meeting at AoM in Chicago:

    Shankar Naskar (University of Virginia at Wise): 10 reviews

    NG Yamini (Indian Institute of Management at Kozhikode): 8 reviews

    Benson Kinney (Louisiana Tech University): 7 reviews

    Antonio Oliveira Jr. (Centro Uni FEI): 7 reviews

    Many reviewers volunteered to review more than their 3 assigned reviews, completing reviews on extra papers assigned to them in the last few days.

    All reviewers, outstanding reviewers, and Champion Reviewer(s) will be recognized publicly, including at AOM 2024.

    With Gratitude,

    Vishal K Gupta

    (2024 ENT Program Chair)

    Vishal Gupta
    University of Alabama
    Tuscaloosa AL
    (205) 348-8427